The Republicans had been fairly positive they’d maintain the mayoral seat in Jacksonville, Florida. In any case, they’ve held the seat for all however 4 of the final three a long time, and have been authorised by the governor. Ron DeSantis (proper), who received re-election by a landslide final 12 months.

They don’t seem to be. Democrat Donna Deegan scored a snug win within the metropolis Tuesday night time.

Colorado Springs has an analogous outcome. Republican Wayne Williams, who sought to exchange fellow Republican John Suthers, misplaced out to impartial Yemi Moboleid.

With these two – unexpectedly! — losses, the Republicans not solely misplaced management of the 2 most populous cities in America, but in addition noticed an additional discount within the variety of massive cities with Republican mayors. The outcomes had been definitely mirrored in present politics, however in addition they mirrored a long-term nationwide pattern away from Republicans in city areas in direction of a celebration in rural areas.

Join Philip Bump’s weekly How To Learn This Chart e-newsletter.

It wasn’t all the time like that. 100 years in the past, solely half of the mayors in America’s 10 most populous cities had been Democrats. That is greater than a 12 months earlier, when there have been solely two. This was partly a mirrored image of regional politics, because the northeast, the place many of the nation’s most populous cities had been situated, was nonetheless largely Republican.

Then this sample started to alter together with the rating of probably the most populous cities within the nation.

(For the needs of the desk under, the social gathering affiliation of a metropolis’s mayor is decided by who served many of the 12 months.)

Whilst not too long ago as 2000, 4 of the ten most populous cities had Republican mayors. In recent times, this determine has been zero.

This in itself is a mirrored image of how the politics of this place have modified over the previous 20 years. The presidential election outcomes present how city areas have shifted to the left and rural areas have shifted to the proper. In 2000, main city counties supported Democrat Al Gore by 18 factors greater than the nationwide margin, whereas rural counties supported George W. Bush by 15 factors extra. In 2020, this hole widened to 27 factors in city areas and 37 factors in rural areas.

Be aware the large soar in rural areas in 2016 when Donald Trump was elected.

The shifts had been surprisingly uniform. Comparatively few rural counties voted extra Democratic in 2020 than they did in 2000. In most locations the shift was to the proper. Within the area from southeast Ohio to northeast Arkansas, the soar was particularly sharp.

Why this shift? Effectively, contemplate a unique tackle the management transition in America’s most populous cities: race and ethnicity.

A century in the past, the mayors of America’s most populous cities had been all the time white males. Step by step this modified. Now, not one of the leaders of the 5 most populous cities is a white particular person. In 2000 there have been three extra.

This coincides with the shift talked about above, when the Northeast moved from strongly Republican to strongly Democratic on account of the civil rights motion. Books have been written about this reversal—Jim Crow’s insurance policies within the South have inspired northern migration, which has inspired White Metropolis residents to maneuver to the suburbs, and so on. This has intensified lately with college-educated Individuals shifting to the left and their tendency to stay in huge cities.

In 2021, The Washington Put up printed a examine wanting into why the hole between city and rural areas is changing into so huge. Conclusion? Race views.

“Racial attitudes amongst all Individuals finest clarify the distinction in voting between rural and concrete areas,” the authors write. “[T]The distinction in ranges of denial of racism amongst rural and concrete Individuals seems to elucidate about three-quarters of the hole between city and rural areas in voting for Trump.”

Findings from the 2023 Kentucky and Pennsylvania Major Election Outcomes

Keep in mind that surge in assist for rural areas in 2016?

We’re speaking about general tendencies right here, not essentially ends in Jacksonville (America’s twelfth most populous metropolis) or Colorado Springs (fortieth most populous). However to some extent, that is how tendencies work: particular person selections based mostly on particular person elements produce outcomes that match into a bigger sample.

Deegan’s victory in Jacksonville means probably the most populous metropolis with a Republican mayor is now Fort Price, the place incumbent Mayor Matty Parker received a second time period earlier this month. Neighboring Dallas has not had a Republican mayor since 2011.

It most likely did not damage Parker’s probabilities that finally 12 months’s occasion she created a long way between herself and her band.


This text initially referred to Mobolade as a Democrat. He’s impartial.